Last Sunday George Will, the bowtie-wearing dean of conservative punditry, published an op-ed in the Washington Post called “More Prisons, Less Crime.” In the piece Will gave prominent attention to his colleagues and fellow travelers Heather Macdonald and James Q. Wilson, citing at length their contention that the record-high level of incarceration in the United States has been beneficial. “For many reasons, including better policing and more incarceration, Americans feel, and are, safer,” he wrote. It was a scattered argument without much substance, but what was most disturbing was the mendacious cherry-picking of data to support the ideological thrust of his argument–which rationalizes increased incarceration and totally dismisses the strong taint of racism in current sentencing policy. Now the Sentencing Project has responded with a welcome corrective, “Do More Prisoners Equal Less Crime?” which dismantles Will’s column point by point to advance a more reality-based take on the relationship between incarceration and crime rates, and on the racist underpinnings of the bloated American prison system.
-
Search It!
-
Recent Entries
-
Links
- A Public Defender
- ABA: Juvenile Justice News
- Act4JJ: Campaign to Reauthorize the JJDPA
- Annie E. Casey Foundation
- Arbitrary and Capricious
- Blueprint Commission: Florida Department of Juvenile Justice
- Books Not Bars (with the Ella Baker Center)
- Building Blocks for Youth
- Campaign for Youth Justice
- Center on Juvenile and Criminal Justice
- Children & the Law
- Children Without Parole
- Coalition for Juvenile Justice
- Correctional Association of New York Juvenile Justice Project
- Corrections Sentencing
- Equal Justice Initiative
- Families & Allies of Virginia’s Youth
- Federal Advisory Committee on Juvenile Justice
- Fight Crime: Invest in Kids
- Grits for Breakfast
- Human Rights Watch: Children’s Rights Division
- Justice 4 Kids
- Justice Policy Institute
- Juvenile Justice Connection
- Juvenile Law Center
- Models for Change
- National Center for Youth Law
- National Juvenile Defender Center
- National Juvenile Justice Network
- Office of Juvenile Justice and Delinquency Prevention
- Prison Law Office
- Public Welfare Foundation
- Sentencing Law and Policy
- Simple Justice
- Stateline: Crime and Courts
- Talk Left
- Teen Advocates USA
- The Real Cost of Prisons
- The Sentencing Project
- Underdog
- Vera Institute Center on Youth Justice
- W. Haywood Burns Institute
- Youth Law Center
- Youth Service America
- Youth Today
- YouTube: JJ Reform Channel
There are two flaws to Mr. Will’s perspectives. One is that most of these arrests, especially in California, are drug related. The laws passed, such as the three strikes laws, are punishing individuals for petty theft and relatively small amounts of narcotics. Secondly, is Mr. Will fine with pushing justice aside and allowing more than 1% of the population to go to jail so others can sleep better? We’re not handling the law or justice properly.